Middlebury President Laurie Patton updates alumni on protest aftermath

Student protesters disrupt speaker Charles Murray on March 2 at McCullough Student Center. Middlebury College photos.

Vermont Business Magazine Middlebury President Laurie Patton emailed college alumni on March 21 to update them on steps the campus community is taking in the aftermath of the much-publicized March 2protestsagainst speaker Charles Murray. She once again condemned the violence, said both college and police investigations are ongoing and that "21st century education must embrace an uncompromising commitment both to free speech and to open dialogue."

President Patton’s note said:

"Dear Middlebury alumni community,

"I know many of you are interested in our progress in response to the Murray event, and I write with a brief update.

"The Middlebury community has joined together in condemning the violence that occurred. There are two investigations underway—the College’s independent investigation of the events of March 2 and, second, a police investigation of the incident outside. The student conduct process underway will be fair and just. Federal law requires that the process and individual outcomes remain confidential, except in the case of criminal violence. Our commitment to this process is absolute.

"In a number of statements to the community, I have reiterated the principle stated in my earlier public letters: a 21st century education must embrace an uncompromising commitment both to free speech and to open dialogue that creates a more inclusive public sphere. Free speech must be defended on all sides, and only through this principle will we achieve the work of making society more inclusive.

"Middlebury has continued with its vibrant hum of classes, sports and artistic events, and outside lectures. We are also hard at work on nourishing the sense of community on our campus that has been under strain these past few weeks. I know you appreciate the importance of that work.

"Yours cordially,
"Laurie Patton, President"

Allison Stanger speaks with Charles Murray in a video session after the initial protests disrupted Murray's speech and before Stanger was injured as they left the building. Middlebury photo.

The Murray protests generated a flood of national news coverage and messages from alumni. Much of the coverage and many of the messages framed the issue as one of free speech on college campuses, others questioned Middlebury’s judgment to invite a speaker whose writings they believe "delegitimize" members of the campus community.

Middlebury has created aninformation pagerelated to the Charles Murray event that includes links to President Patton’s statements, news coverage, statements by Charles Murray and Professor Allison Stanger, and a wide variety of opinion pieces submitted to the student newspaper.

Opinions from The Campus

Do Better Middlebury, Ben Arquit ’20, 3/9/17

We Can Do Better, Annie Grayer, 3/8/17

Charles Murray, Middlebury, the Working Class and the Rise of Trump’s America, Charles Smith ’20, 3/8/17

A Disappointing Response, Adin Insoft ’20, 3/8/17

Unwittingly Promoting Murray, R. Curtis Brand, 3/8/17

We Got Played Last Week, Day Robins ’17, 3/8/17

This Is Not My Protest, James Scott ’19, 3/8/17

Illiberalism on Display, Richard W. Porter ’81, 3/8/17

I realized that I had done exactly what we never want anyone in our classroom to do..., Bettina Matthias, professor of German, director of the German School, 3/8/17

The Need for More Protests, Divesh "Parli" Rizal, 3/8/17

A Sad Day on Campus, Ata Anzali, assistant professor of religion, 3/8/17

Murray Should Not Have Been Invited, Peter Knobler ’68, 3/8/17

Vilification from the Protesters, Wentao Zhai ’17, 3/8/17

Rethinking the Consequences of Neutrality, Tyler McDowell ’19, 3/8/17

Deeply Disturbed by Silencing,Jacob M. Appel MD JD, 3/8/17

Toward Community Healing,Jeremy Stratton-Smith ’17, 3/8/17

Why We Should Listen to the Protesters, Juan Andrade-Vera ’19, 3/8/17

Shine a Light on Abhorrent Ideas, Peter Mandel ’79, 3/8/17

Questions for Those Who Shut Down Murray, David Stoll, professor of anthropology, 3/8/17

Nuance, Free Speech, and Responsibility, Erik Bleich, professor of political science, 3/8/17

Letter from Abroad, 3/8/17

Free Speech vs. Elevated Speech, Elizabeth Lee ’17, 3/8/17

Why We Protest,Anna Jacobsen ’16.5, Joshua Claxton ’18 and Austin Kahn ’17.5, 3/18/17

Coming Together, Thomas Leaycraft ’20, opinions editor, 3/8/17

Developing the Campus Dialogue, Campus Editorial Board, 3/8/17

Selected Media Coverage

March 10, 2017:Is Intersectionality a Religion?,New York Magazine, Andrew Sullivan

March 11, 2017:The Dangerous Safety of College,New York Times, Frank Bruni

March 7, 2017:Why Middlebury's Violent Response to Charles Murray Reminded Me of the Little Rock Nine,Washington Post, Danielle Allen

March 7, 2017:Protest Prompts Professors To Defend Free Speech,Fox News/Tucker Carlson Tonight

March 7, 2017:Discord at Middlebury: Students on the Anti-Murray Protests,New York Times

March 7, 2017:After a protest turns violent, Middlebury finds a teaching moment for free speech,Boston Globe

March 6, 2017:The Aftermath at Middlebury, by Scott Jaschik,Inside Higher Ed.

March 5, 2017:Bell Curve Author Attacked by Protesters at Middlebury College,Boston Globe

March 4, 2017:Murray and Middlebury: What Happened and What Should Be Done, by Professor Matthew Dickinson

March 3, 2017:A Sad Day on the Middlebury College Campus, by Professor Ata Anzali,Addison Independent

Source: Middlebury 3.23.2017