June revenue results down in Vermont, fiscal year results up $7 million

A flurry of tax refunds sent June tax revenue results down for the month, but the state will still finish the fiscal year more than $7 million ahead of expectations and are well over the actual numbers reported last year (see tables below).
Secretary of Administration Jeb Spaulding released the Preliminary June 2012 General Fund (GF) revenue results on Friday. June is the final month of fiscal year (FY) 2012; changes to these results are possible as the fiscal year close-out process is finalized. Preliminary General Fund revenues totaled $110.68 million for June 2012, and were -$2.82 million or -2.49% below the $113.50 million consensus revenue forecast for the month. Year end preliminary General Fund revenues were $1.196 billion, and +$7.19 million or +0.60% above the full year target of $1.189 billion for FY 2012. The FY 2012 results through June also exceed the same period for the prior fiscal year (FY 2011) by 2.47%.
‘Overall, we are pleased to have exceeded the full fiscal year target by +$7.19 million or +0.60% and the prior fiscal year’s revenues by +$28.84 million or 2.47%, despite experiencing some slippage for the month of June. Our three major revenue components performed quite nicely compared to last year; personal income tax receipts were up 7.9%, sales & use tax receipts were up 5.0%, and meals & rooms tax receipts were up 3.5%. The unanticipated revenues will be used to fund reconstruction of the Waterbury State Office Complex and other State facility needs resulting from Tropical Storm Irene,’explained Secretary Spaulding.
Spaulding continued, ‘It is worth noting that despite the moderate growth in revenues over the last two years, we finished the fiscal year ending June 30 just about level with where we were four fiscal years earlier. The General Fund revenue ‘high water’mark of $1.199 billion was achieved for FY 2008, prior to the economic recession, compared to $1.196 billion for the year just closed.’
Current targets reflect the Fiscal Year 2012 Consensus Revenue Forecast adopted by the Emergency Board at their January 18, 2012 meeting. Statutorily, the State is required to revise the Consensus Revenue Forecast two times per year, in January and July; the Emergency Board may schedule interim revisions if deemed necessary. The next Emergency Board meeting is scheduled for Friday July 20, 2012.
Net Personal Income Tax (PI) receipts are the largest single state revenue source providing approximately 50% of total GF revenue. PI Tax receipts are reported Net-of-Personal Income Tax refunds. Net Personal Income Tax is comprised of PI Withholding Tax, PI Estimated Payments, PI Refunds, PI Paid, and PI Other.
Net PI receipts for June were $59.43 million, -$2.81 million or -4.52% behind the monthly target of $62.24 million. The year to date Net PI Tax receipts of $597.01 million were +0.40% above the cumulative target of $594.60 million. The cumulative results are +7.91% ahead of the same period for the prior fiscal year (FY 2011).
Secretary Spaulding commented, ‘We experienced greater refund activity both in the month of June (-$4.37 million) and for the full year (-$14.54 million) than anticipated in the target. These results were offset by favorable results for the year in PI Paid Returns, PI Estimates and PI Other (+$16.56 million, +3.64 million and +$5.48 million respectively). As was expected, PI Withholdings ended the year unfavorable to target by $8.73 million.’
Corporate Income Taxes are also reported net of refunds. Net Corporate Income Tax receipts for June of $14.31 million resulted in recovering most of the previous negative results in this category. Year to date Corporate receipts were $85.92 million, +$8.62 million or +11.16% ahead of target.
Spaulding explained, ‘As projected last month, Net Corporate Income Tax receipts remained above target through the final month of this fiscal year (FY 2012). Unfortunately, as compared to the same period for the prior year (FY 2011), Net Corporate Income Taxes fell short by -4.16%.’
Consumption tax results for June exceeded target: Sales & Use Tax receipts of $18.19 million were above target by +$0.35 million (+1.99%); and Rooms & Meals Tax receipts of $9.31 million exceeded target by +$0.18 million (+2.02%). Year to date, Sales & Use Tax receipts of $227.89 million exceed target by +0.60%, while Rooms & Meals Tax receipts of $126.91 million were +0.17% ahead of the target for the current fiscal year (FY 2012). Compared to the results for the same period of the prior fiscal year (FY 2011), cumulative June consumption taxes (Sales & Use; Meals & Rooms) exceeded the prior year results by +4.98% and +3.49% respectively.
Spaulding commented, ‘It is heartening to see the consumption taxes exceeding both the current year target and the prior year, despite the relatively snowless winter and slow economic recovery. We will see if this trend is projected to continue when the State’s two economists present their consensus revenue recommendations on July 12th.’
The remaining non-major tax components include Insurance, Inheritance & Estate Tax, Real Property Transfer Tax, and ‘Other’(which includes: Bank Franchise Tax, Telephone Tax, Liquor Tax, Beverage Tax, Fees, and Other Taxes). The results for the remaining non-major categories for June were as follows: Insurance Tax, $0.29 million (-77.41%); Inheritance & Estate Tax, $0.04 million (-97.05%); Property Transfer Tax, $0.90 million (+3.78%); and ‘Other’, $8.20 million (+6.33%). The year to date June results for the remaining non-major categories were: Insurance Tax, $56.35 million (+0.62%); Inheritance & Estate Tax, $13.33 million (-31.62%); Property Transfer Tax, $7.86 million (-5.89%); and ‘Other’, $81.28 million (+1.11%). Cumulatively, the year to date non-major components total of $158.83 million through June 2012, is -11.84% below the receipts for the same period of FY 2011 (reduced for a one-time settlement received in August of FY 2011).
General Fund By Major Element (In Millions)*

Fiscal Tax Component

June Target

June Revenue

$ Change

% Change

FY Target

FY Revenue

$ Change

% Change

Personal Income

62.24

59.43

-2.81

-4.52%

594.60

597.01

2.41

0.40%

Sales & Use

17.84

18.19

0.35

1.99%

226.53

227.89

1.36

0.60%

Corporate

12.97

14.31

1.35

10.39%

77.30

85.92

8.62

11.16%

Meals & Room

9.13

9.31

0.18

2.02%

126.70

126.91

0.21

0.17%

Insurance Premium

1.28

0.29

-0.99

-77.41%

56.00

56.35

0.35

0.62%

Inheritance & Estate

1.47

0.04

-1.43

-97.05%

19.50

13.33

-6.17

-31.62%

Real Prop. Transfer

0.87

0.90

0.03

3.78%

8.35

7.86

-0.49

-5.89%

Other

7.72

8.20

0.49

6.33%

80.39

81.28

0.90

1.11%

Total

113.50

110.68

-2.82

-2.49%

1189.37

1196.56

7.19

0.60%

Transportation Fund
Secretary Spaulding also released the non-dedicated Transportation Fund Revenue for June. Total non-dedicated Transportation Fund receipts of $23.14 million for the month fell below target by -$2.43 million (-9.52%), compared to the monthly target of $25.57 million. The cumulative June Transportation Fund receipts of $221.81 million are below the $225.17 million target by -1.49%. Year to date June FY 2012 non-dedicated Transportation Funds exceed the prior year (FY 2011) results by 1.93% for the same period.
Four (4) of the five (5) individual tax components of the Transportation Fund revenue were below target for the month as well as the full year, including Gasoline Tax, Motor Vehicle Purchase & Use Tax, Motor Vehicle Fees, and Other. Only the Diesel Tax component was essentially on target for the month and exceeded the full year target. Individual Transportation Fund revenue components for June were: Gasoline Tax, $5.05 million or -6.22% below target; Diesel Tax, $1.98 million or -0.07% above target; Motor Vehicle Purchase & Use Tax, $6.31 million or -15.48% below target; Motor Vehicle Fees, $8.16 million or -5.15% below target; and Other Fees, $1.63 million or -23.39% below the monthly target. Year to date results for the individual Transportation Fund revenue components for June were: Gasoline Tax, $59.28 million or -2.33% short of target; Diesel Tax, $16.00 million or +1.92% above target; Motor Vehicle Purchase & Use Tax, $54.60 million or -1.20% below target; Motor Vehicle Fees, $73.64 million or -1.02% behind target; and Other Fees, $18.28 million or -4.30% short of the target.
Spaulding said, ‘Cumulative Transportation Fund receipts for June were disappointing, resulting in below target performance for the full FY 2012. Hopefully, the reduced gas prices at the pump, for the summer vacation season, will spur better results going into FY 2013.’
The Secretary also reported on the results for the Transportation Infrastructure Bond Fund (’TIB’). TIB Fund Gas receipts for June were $1.81 million or +3.84% above target; year to date TIB Gas receipts were $20.92 million or +1.54% ahead of target. TIB Fund Diesel receipts for the month were $0.24 million or -21.07% behind the monthly target; year to date TIB Diesel receipts were $1.92 million or -8.55% short of target. The TIB Fund receipts are noted on the following table:
Transportation Fund By Major Element (In Millions)*

Fiscal Tax Component

June Target

June Revenue

$ Change

% Change

FY Target

FY Revenue

$ Change

% Change

Gasoline

5.38

5.05

-0.33

-6.22%

60.70

59.28

-1.42

-2.33%

Diesel Fuel

1.98

1.98

0.00

-0.07%

15.70

16.00

0.30

1.92%

MV Purchase & Use

7.47

6.31

-1.16

-15.48%

55.27

54.60

-0.66

-1.20%

Motor Vehicle Fees

8.60

8.16

-0.44

-5.15%

74.40

73.64

-0.76

-1.02%

Other

2.13

1.63

-0.50

-23.39%

19.10

18.28

-0.82

-4.30%

Total

25.57

23.14

-2.43

-9.52%

225.17

221.81

-3.36

-1.49%

Education Fund
Today, Secretary Spaulding released the ‘non-Property Tax’Education Fund revenues (which constitute approximately 12% of the total Education Fund sources). The non-Property Tax Education Fund receipts for June totaled $13.54 million, or -$1.43 million (-9.54%) below the $14.96 million target for the month. Year to date, non-Property Tax Education Fund receipts were $162.05 million, or -0.16% short of the year to date target. An as yet undetermined upward revision to the Lottery Transfer is expected after the final reconciliation of fiscal year close-out. This adjustment may well bring the Education Fund results up to or slightly in excess of the full year target.
The preliminary individual Education Fund revenue component results for June were: Sales & Use Tax, $9.09 million, or +1.99% above target; Motor Vehicle Purchase & Use Tax, $3.16 million or -15.48%; Lottery Transfer, $1.29 million or -43.51%; Education Fund Interest for June was less than $.02 million for the month against a target of -$01 million. Year to date receipts by component were: Sales & Use Tax, $113.94 million, or +0.60% above target; Motor Vehicle Purchase & Use Tax, $27.30 million or -1.20%; Lottery Transfer, $20.76 million or -2.54% behind target; year to date Education Fund Interest for June was under $0.10 million against a target of approximately $0.04 million. The non-property tax current fiscal year to date Education Fund receipts are 4.08% ahead of the FY 2011 results for the same period.

Conclusion
Secretary Spaulding concluded, ‘June results were less than we had expected. Nevertheless, we are pleased that the preliminary General Fund results for fiscal year 2012 came in above target for the year and continue to grow. We look forward to the Emergency Board’s adoption of revised revenue forecasts for Fiscal Year 2013 and beyond, at their meeting on July 20, 2012.’
Note: All results are preliminary and subject to change as the fiscal year end closing process proceeds.
Comparative Statement of Revenues

General Fund As of June 30, 2012

Preliminary

Total to Date

Total to Date

Last Year

This Year

% of Change

Taxes

Personal Income

$553,265,451

$597,006,650

7.91%

Sales & Use

217,082,665

227,892,414

4.98%

Corporate

89,652,888

85,923,624

-4.16%

Meals & Room

122,628,019

126,912,552

3.49%

Liquor & Wine

15,350,160

16,428,915

7.03%

Insurance Premium

54,991,370

56,345,855

2.46%

Telephone Gross Receipts

223,440

208,063

-6.88%

Telephone Property

11,136,141

9,415,453

-15.45%

Beverage

5,786,559

5,974,632

3.25%

Electric Generating

2,921,398

2,930,157

0.30%

Inheritance & Estate

35,879,828

13,334,885

-62.83%

Real Property Transfer

8,377,522

7,859,404

-6.18%

Bank Franchise

15,423,985

10,658,134

-30.90%

All Other Taxes

3,719,089

1,235,985

-66.77%

Total Taxes

1,136,438,515

1,162,126,723

2.26%

Other Revenues

Business Licenses

2,964,818

3,032,423

2.28%

Fees

20,464,581

20,420,436

-0.22%

Services

1,131,906

2,329,880

105.84%

Fines, Forfeits & Penalties

5,721,226

7,361,709

28.67%

Interest, Prem

255,257

395,072

54.77%

Special Assessments

0

0

0.00%

All Other Revenues

746,786

894,082

19.72%

Total Other Revenues

31,284,573

34,433,602

10.07%

Total General Fund

1,167,723,089

1,196,560,325

2.47%

Note: Revenue Estimates are fiscal year total estimates.

Prepared by Department of Finance & Management

Date: July 10, 2012